📰A Nation of Entrepreneurs?

Yash takes a trip to India and tells us what he learned.

Welcome to Samosa Capital’s daily briefing — the best way to stay up-to-date on India’s financial markets. Every Friday, we bring you a long-form reflection on Indian markets: today, Yash shares insights from his trip to India.

Have a question you want us to answer? Fill out this form and you could be featured in our newsletter.

—Shreyas, shreyas@samosacapital.com

Market Update

Live Event

Seats are running out for our upcoming “Future of India” expert panel and networking event on Wednesday, February 12, 2025, in New York City. Buy now here, or earn a free ticket by sharing Samosa Capital with three friends.

Reflections From My Trip to India: A Nation of Entrepreneurs?

Hi all, Yash here. I took a trip to India recently, seeing the beautiful cities of Surat, Bombay, and Jaipur.

While visiting family, it occurred to me that only two were formally employed in salaried jobs. In fact, most people I met were self-employed or owned their businesses. The data backs this up: only 20 percent of the Indian labor force, or 130 million people, have a salaried job. Even among them, only 42 percent have a written official contract, 48 percent have no paid leave, and 54 percent lack any social security benefits. 

India’s economy is structurally informal: the remaining 80 percent without salaried jobs work at the 77 million unregistered informal enterprises running at the household level, such as small stores. 20 percent of the Indian workforce are “casual workers,” who work long hours on someone else’s farm, construction site, small store, or as help in a residence to earn daily or periodic wages.

How it compares: India still lags behind China (55 percent), Sri Lanka (58 percent), and a global leader in the US (90 percent). This reveals some deeper faults in India: 25 percent of the population remains illiterate, compared to China’s 3 percent and Sri Lanka’s 7.5 percent. Additionally, India suffers from a severe underemployment crisis: two-thirds of India’s unemployed youth are educated, but cannot find jobs better than working on farms. Low-level government jobs that require basic literacy, like checking tickets on a train, get countless applications from doctors, lawyers, and PhDs.

NOTE: Hourly workers with formal contracts and consistent hours are included among salaried workers in the data.

With a vast informal economy, who will pay the taxes? 2.2 percent of Indians pay any income tax: that’s 100 million taxpayers in an economy of 575 million workers and a population of 1.3 billion. This means local and national governments squeeze tax through high sales taxes: 27 percent on ‘luxury goods,’ 18 percent on electronics and services, 12 percent on clothing and certain medicines, and 5 percent on essentials. I live in New York City, with an 8.5 percent sales tax rate, and most people think that is outrageous. Without a formal business sector with employees, India funds essential services through a highly regressive tax system.

Gupshup

Macro

Equities

Alts

Policy

See you Monday.

Written by Yash Tibrewal. Edited by Shreyas Sinha.

Disclaimer: This is not financial advice or recommendation for any investment. The Content is for informational purposes only, you should not construe any such information or other material as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice.