• Samosa Capital
  • Posts
  • 📰India’s Surveillance Program Ends As Soon As It Starts | Daily India Briefing

📰India’s Surveillance Program Ends As Soon As It Starts | Daily India Briefing

Everything you need to know about Indian markets.

Today, we breakdown India’s announcement for all smartphones to include a mandatory tracking app, which was reversed soon after.

If you have any questions about India, fill out this form or reach out to Shreyas at [email protected]

Macro

Equities

Alts

Policy

AI is all the rage, but are you using it to your advantage?

Successful AI transformation starts with deeply understanding your organization’s most critical use cases. We recommend this practical guide from You.com that walks through a proven framework to identify, prioritize, and document high-value AI opportunities. Learn more with this AI Use Case Discovery Guide.

Reach out to [email protected] to reach our audience and see your advertisement here.

India’s Surveillance Program Ends As Soon As It Starts

India’s attempt to force a government-developed tracking and anti-fraud app onto every newly manufactured or imported smartphone triggered one of the strongest public privacy backlashes the country has seen in years, causing the policy to collapse faster than it was announced.

The original order gave companies like Apple, Samsung, and Xiaomi ninety days to ensure “Sanchar Saathi,” developed by the Indian government’s Dept of Telecommunications, was preinstalled. This made it clear the government wanted the app embedded at the operating-system layer, not as a regular deletable app. That level of access is significant because Sanchar Saathi has permissions far beyond theft-prevention tools: it can make and manage phone calls, send messages, access data logs, read files, use the camera, and check locations. Critics immediately framed the requirement as a mass-surveillance tool disguised as a cybersecurity measure.

Opposition leaders like Priyanka Gandhi accused the government of using fraud prevention as a pretext to monitor citizens’ digital lives. Digital-rights advocates noted that since the government exempted itself from India’s 2023 Data Protection Act, nothing in law prevents the state from collecting or linking the extremely sensitive data the app could potentially access. Civil society groups warned that a mandated, high-privilege app installed on every device created a single point of failure from a cybersecurity perspective, especially in a country where the government has already been criticized for building vast, unsegmented data linkages between databases.

Compounding the uproar was historical memory. India’s Pegasus scandal (where journalists, opposition politicians, activists, and the ruling party were targeted) has made trust in state digital surveillance almost nonexistent. Apple has clashed with Delhi before over alleged state-sponsored intrusion attempts. Against that backdrop, the idea of a compulsory government app with deep device permissions was politically toxic.

Within a day, the Modi government began backpedaling. Communications Minister Scindia insisted the app could be removed at any time, despite the original order contradicting that claim. By Wednesday, the mandate was formally withdrawn. Officials justified the reversal by pointing to the app’s rising popularity (14 million downloads, 2,000 frauds reported daily, and 600,000 new users in one day), arguing that voluntary uptake made compulsion unnecessary.

Digital-rights organizations called the withdrawal a positive step but stressed that the government has not yet published the revised legal order or clarified whether new directions under the Cyber Security Rules will replace the original mandate. For them, this is not closure but a temporary pause; the structural concerns about unchecked state access to personal data remain unresolved.

While the misstep has ended, it reveals internal ambitions within the Indian government to better track citizens. How this comes to fruition in other ways will be worth keeping a close eye on.

See you tomorrow.

Written by Yash Tibrewal. Edited by Shreyas Sinha.

Sponsor the next newsletter to reach tens of thousands of U.S.-based business-savvy professionals. Reach out to [email protected].

Could your business use expert insights to power growth in India? Reach out to [email protected] for a free introductory call.

Disclaimer: This is not financial advice or recommendation for any investment. The Content is for informational purposes only, you should not construe any such information or other material as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice.